Reference

The Protocol Index

A ranked assessment of 25 significant projects in AI, generative, and blockchain art. Updated quarterly.

Version 1.0 · Last updated 2025-01-07

Methodology

The Protocol Index scores projects across four dimensions of circulation criticism. Each dimension is rated 1-5, producing a composite score out of 20. Rankings reflect diagnostic assessment, not aesthetic preference.

CR/5

Conceptual Rigor

Does the work engage seriously with its medium? Does it take a position or merely produce?

TI/5

Technical Innovation

Does the work push infrastructure forward? Does it create new possibilities or replicate existing patterns?

CD/5

Circulation Design

How intentionally does the work design its own distribution? Does it exploit or critique its platforms?

CP/5

Critical Position

Does the work make its conditions visible? Is it complicit, critical, or symptomatic?

Rankings

01

Spawning / Have I Been Trained

Holly Herndon & Mat Dryhurst · 2022-ongoing

Infrastructure

CR

5

TI

5

CD

5

CP

5

20/20

The rare project that operates critically at every level. Spawning doesn't make AI art—it makes the infrastructure for consent in AI training visible and actionable. Have I Been Trained lets artists check if their work was scraped; Source.Plus lets them opt in or out. This is circulation criticism as practice, not just commentary. The work is the tool; the tool reshapes the field.

02

Autoglyphs

Larva Labs · 2019

Generative

CR

5

TI

5

CD

5

CP

4

19/20

Fully on-chain generative art before the category existed. The work is the contract; the contract is the work. No external dependencies, no IPFS, no metadata servers. Autoglyphs will exist as long as Ethereum exists. This is not just technical purity—it's a statement about what permanence means in protocol contexts. The scarcity is real because the constraint is real.

03

Fidenza

Tyler Hobbs · 2021

Generative

CR

5

TI

4

CD

5

CP

4

18/20

The work that defined Art Blocks' aesthetic and market position. Hobbs understood that generative art's power lies in the tension between algorithmic constraint and emergent beauty. Fidenza's flow fields create genuine visual pleasure without sacrificing conceptual seriousness. The secondary market success was not an accident but a function of the work's legibility—beautiful enough to collect, complex enough to study.

04

Botto

Mario Klingemann + DAO · 2021-ongoing

AI / DAO

CR

5

TI

4

CD

4

CP

5

18/20

The most rigorous experiment in decentralized artistic agency. Botto generates images; token holders vote on which to mint; the feedback loop trains the model. This is not AI as tool but AI as artist-governed-by-collective. The question it poses—can authorship be distributed across human and machine collectives?—is more interesting than most answers.

05

Quantum

Kevin McCoy · 2014

Historical

CR

4

TI

5

CD

4

CP

4

17/20

The first NFT, minted on Namecoin before Ethereum existed. Quantum's significance is primarily historical—it established the template that everything else follows. But it also demonstrates that the NFT was not a sudden invention but an idea waiting for infrastructure. McCoy saw the possibility; the market took a decade to catch up.

06

Ringers

Dmitri Cherniak · 2021

Generative

CR

4

TI

4

CD

5

CP

4

17/20

Elegant constraint: wrap a string around pegs. The simplicity of the algorithm belies the complexity of the outputs. Ringers proved that generative art could achieve the recognizability required for blue-chip status—you know a Ringer when you see one. The work's circulation success is a function of its visual coherence.

07

CryptoPunks

Larva Labs · 2017

PFP / Historical

CR

3

TI

5

CD

5

CP

4

17/20

Less interesting as images than as format. CryptoPunks established the 10K PFP model, the rarity trait system, the floor-price dynamics that now structure the entire NFT market. The work's conceptual contribution is infrastructural—it created a template for artificial scarcity that thousands of projects copied. The 'punk' branding is ironic; the social formation is oligarchic.

08

Chromie Squiggle

Snowfro (Erick Calderon) · 2020

Generative

CR

4

TI

4

CD

5

CP

3

16/20

Art Blocks' genesis project and proof of concept. The Squiggle is deliberately simple—a colored line with varying properties—because its purpose was to demonstrate the platform, not to be a masterwork. That it became a status object anyway reveals how market dynamics can transform demonstration into canon.

09

Merge

Pak · 2021

Conceptual

CR

5

TI

4

CD

4

CP

3

16/20

The $91.8M Nifty Gateway sale that redefined what an NFT drop could be. Merge's innovation was deflationary mechanics: tokens combine when transferred, reducing supply over time. The work is less about the visual (black and white circles) than the economic game theory. Pak understands that in the NFT space, the mechanism is the meaning.

10

Terraforms

Mathcastles · 2021

Generative / On-chain

CR

5

TI

5

CD

3

CP

3

16/20

Fully on-chain ASCII landscapes generated from a 'hypercastle' data structure. Terraforms pushes the technical limits of what can exist in a smart contract—each piece is computed, not stored. The work is dense, difficult, and rewards close attention. Its relative market underperformance compared to more accessible projects is itself diagnostic.

11

DEAFBEEF

DEAFBEEF · 2021-ongoing

Audiovisual / On-chain

CR

5

TI

4

CD

4

CP

3

16/20

On-chain audiovisual works generated from C code stored in the contract. DEAFBEEF's commitment to full on-chain storage is ideological—a refusal of the external dependencies that make most NFTs fragile. The work sounds like machines thinking, which is appropriate given its substrate.

12

Refik Anadol Data Sculptures

Refik Anadol · 2015-ongoing

AI / Installation

CR

3

TI

4

CD

4

CP

3

14/20

The most visible AI art practice in institutional contexts. Anadol's data sculptures are spectacular—undulating walls of machine-learned imagery, cathedral-scale projections, immersive environments. The question is whether spectacle substitutes for criticality. The work visualizes data without interrogating it, celebrates AI without questioning it. Beautiful and symptomatic.

13

Abstract Browsing

Rafael Rozendaal · 2014-ongoing

Net Art / Software

CR

4

TI

3

CD

4

CP

4

15/20

The browser plugin that turns any website into geometric abstraction. MoMA's acquisition in 2024 raised questions about what it means to collect software that remains freely distributed. The work is a readymade for the network era—it reframes infrastructure as aesthetic object without removing it from circulation.

14

Harm van den Dorpel Practice

Harm van den Dorpel · 2015-ongoing

Generative / Conceptual

CR

5

TI

4

CD

3

CP

3

15/20

Rigorous generative practice rooted in evolutionary algorithms and formal systems. Van den Dorpel's work is intellectually demanding—each project is a research program as much as an art series. The market has not rewarded this difficulty, which itself reveals the tension between conceptual ambition and collectibility.

15

XCOPY

XCOPY · 2018-ongoing

Crypto Art

CR

3

TI

3

CD

5

CP

3

14/20

Glitch aesthetics and dystopian imagery that defined early crypto art's visual language. XCOPY's success is a function of timing, consistency, and community—an artist who was there early, kept making work, and built loyalty. The images are memorable without being complex; the circulation is optimized for the platforms.

16

Art Blocks Platform

Snowfro + Artists · 2020-ongoing

Platform

CR

3

TI

5

CD

4

CP

2

14/20

The infrastructure that made generative NFTs legible to markets. Art Blocks is not a single artwork but a system for producing and distributing artworks—a factory with curatorial functions. Its success created the category; its curation shapes what generative art gets seen. Platform as medium, platform as gatekeeper.

17

Forgotten Runes

Dotta + Team · 2021-ongoing

PFP / Worldbuilding

CR

3

TI

3

CD

5

CP

2

13/20

The most ambitious worldbuilding project in the PFP space. Forgotten Runes treats NFTs as characters in an expandable narrative universe—lore, animation, community storytelling. The work's interest lies in its participatory fiction model, not its pixel art. Whether this is art or entertainment is a question the project productively blurs.

18

Sarah Friend Practice

Sarah Friend · 2018-ongoing

Conceptual / Blockchain

CR

5

TI

3

CD

2

CP

4

14/20

Smart contract art that interrogates the social implications of blockchain systems. Friend's work—Lifeforms (tokens that die if not transferred), Off (collective action coordination)—treats Ethereum as a site for social experiment, not just a platform for distribution. The work circulates poorly because it's designed to create friction, not flow.

19

Rhea Myers Practice

Rhea Myers · 2014-ongoing

Conceptual / Blockchain

CR

5

TI

3

CD

2

CP

5

15/20

The earliest and most rigorous blockchain art practice. Myers was making art about and on blockchains years before NFTs became a market. Works like 'Is Art' (a contract that returns whether its contents are art) and 'Secret Artwork' (encrypted art you own but cannot see) are conceptual art updated for protocol conditions. Undervalued by markets, essential to history.

20

Jonas Lund Practice

Jonas Lund · 2013-ongoing

Conceptual / Data

CR

5

TI

3

CD

3

CP

4

15/20

Art about art world systems—algorithms that optimize for success, tokens that give collectors voting rights on the artist's career, paintings generated from market data. Lund makes the feedback loops between art and market explicit, turning circulation itself into material. The work is diagnostic by design.

21

Kevin Abosch 1111

Kevin Abosch · 2018

Conceptual

CR

4

TI

3

CD

3

CP

3

13/20

10 million ERC-20 tokens representing the artist's blood-infused physical artwork. Abosch's token experiments explore fungibility and identity—what does it mean to own a fraction of an artwork, of a self? The work anticipates later fractionalization trends while remaining rooted in conceptual art's dematerialization tradition.

22

Ian Cheng Emissaries

Ian Cheng · 2015-2017

Simulation

CR

5

TI

4

CD

2

CP

3

14/20

Live simulations that run indefinitely, generating emergent narratives from AI agents. Cheng's work predates the NFT boom and circulates primarily through institutions, not markets. The Emissaries trilogy treats simulation as a medium for exploring agency, evolution, and worldbuilding—serious work that resists easy tokenization.

23

Matt Kane Gazers

Matt Kane · 2021

Generative

CR

4

TI

3

CD

4

CP

3

14/20

Lunar-cycle-synced generative paintings that change with the moon. Gazers introduced time-based dynamics to generative NFTs—the work you own today looks different than it will next week. Kane's practice bridges traditional painting concerns (color, composition) with protocol-native possibilities (on-chain time, evolving state).

24

Bright Moments

Collective · 2021-ongoing

Platform / Event

CR

3

TI

3

CD

4

CP

2

12/20

IRL minting events as art world activations. Bright Moments understands that NFTs are social technologies—the experience of minting together, in person, creates community and memory. The model is less about the art than about the event; the event is less about the art than about the network it produces.

25

Hito Steyerl AI Works

Hito Steyerl · 2019-ongoing

Video / Installation

CR

5

TI

2

CD

2

CP

5

14/20

The most critically rigorous artist working with AI themes in institutional contexts. Steyerl's video essays (This is the Future, Power Plants) interrogate AI's political implications—labor, surveillance, militarization—without celebrating the technology. The work circulates through biennials and museums, not markets, which preserves its critical distance.

How to Cite

Sauer, Sara. “The Protocol Index v1.0.” PROTOCOL, 2025-01-07. https://sarasauer.com/index

The Protocol Index is updated quarterly. Disagreements, corrections, and nominations for inclusion can be directed to Amanda Schmitt.

← Back to PROTOCOL